Tax-deductible contributions now, taxed withdrawals in retirement
After-tax contributions now, tax-free withdrawals in retirement
Pay taxes now (Roth) vs. pay taxes later (Traditional)
Personal Information
IRA Contributions
Tax Information
Advanced Options
Advanced features including RMD calculations, state taxes, and inheritance planning will be available in the full version.
Compare Multiple Scenarios
Compare different contribution amounts, retirement ages, and tax scenarios side-by-side.
IRA Comparison Results
| Metric | Roth IRA | Traditional IRA | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Contributions | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Total Growth | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Tax Paid Now | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Tax Paid at Retirement | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Net After-Tax Value | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Recommendation
Based on your inputs, we recommend the Roth IRA because you're in a lower tax bracket now than you expect to be in retirement.
Choose Roth IRA if:
- You're in a low tax bracket now
- You expect higher taxes in retirement
- You want tax-free withdrawals
- You don't need tax deduction now
Choose Traditional IRA if:
- You're in a high tax bracket now
- You expect lower taxes in retirement
- You need tax deduction now
- You want to reduce current taxable income
Key Differences Explained
Tax Treatment
Roth: Pay taxes now, withdraw tax-free. Traditional: Tax deduction now, pay taxes when withdrawing.
Withdrawal Rules
Roth: Contributions can be withdrawn anytime tax-free. Traditional: Withdrawals taxed as income.
Required Minimum Distributions
Roth: No RMDs during your lifetime. Traditional: Must start RMDs at age 73 (75 if born 1960+).
Related Calculators
Frequently Asked Quentions
Need a Custom Tool?
Contact our team to build a custom calculator.
What is a Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA Calculator?
A Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA calculator is a sophisticated financial tool designed to help investors compare the long-term outcomes of these two popular retirement account options. This calculator analyzes key variables including your current age, retirement timeline, income level, tax brackets, contribution amounts, and expected investment returns to project which IRA type could potentially yield higher after-tax retirement income.
The fundamental difference between Roth and Traditional IRAs lies in their tax treatment. With a Traditional IRA, you typically get a tax deduction for contributions in the year you make them, but you pay ordinary income tax on withdrawals during retirement. Conversely, a Roth IRA offers no upfront tax deduction—you contribute with after-tax dollars—but qualified withdrawals in retirement are completely tax-free, including all investment growth.
How the IRA Comparison Calculator Works
Our advanced calculator uses compound interest formulas and tax calculations to provide accurate projections:
Key Calculation Components:
- Contribution Period: Calculates years until retirement based on your current age and planned retirement age
- Annual Contributions: Applies IRS contribution limits ($7,000 for 2024, $8,000 if age 50+)
- Investment Growth: Uses compound interest formula: FV = P × [(1 + r)^n – 1] / r
- Tax Calculations: Applies current and expected future tax rates to determine after-tax value
- Inflation Consideration: Optional adjustment for purchasing power preservation
When to Use This Calculator
This comparison tool is particularly valuable in several scenarios:
Critical Decision Points:
- Choosing between Roth and Traditional IRA for the first time
- Evaluating whether to convert an existing Traditional IRA to Roth
- Planning retirement savings strategy based on expected tax changes
- Determining optimal contribution amounts within IRS limits
- Assessing impact of changing income levels on IRA eligibility
Mathematical Formulas Behind the Calculations
Future Value Formula for Regular Contributions:
FV = P × [(1 + r)^n – 1] / r
Where:
FV = Future Value
P = Annual contribution
r = Annual rate of return (decimal)
n = Number of years
After-Tax Value Calculations:
Traditional IRA After-Tax Value:
= FV × (1 – Retirement Tax Rate)
Roth IRA After-Tax Value:
= [Annual Contribution × (1 – Current Tax Rate)] × Growth Factor
Real-World Calculation Example
Let’s examine a practical scenario:
Example Scenario:
Assumptions:
- Age: 35 years old
- Retirement Age: 65
- Annual Contribution: $6,500
- Current Tax Rate: 24%
- Expected Retirement Tax Rate: 22%
- Annual Return: 7%
- Contribution Years: 30
Traditional IRA Calculation:
- Future Value: $6500 × [(1.07^30 – 1) / 0.07] = $6500 × 94.46 = $613,990
- Tax at Withdrawal: $613,990 × 22% = $135,078
- After-Tax Value: $613,990 – $135,078 = $478,912
Roth IRA Calculation:
- After-Tax Contribution: $6500 × (1 – 0.24) = $4,940
- Future Value: $4940 × 94.46 = $466,632
- Tax at Withdrawal: $0 (tax-free)
- After-Tax Value: $466,632
Result: In this scenario, Traditional IRA provides $12,280 more after-tax value, making it the better choice despite the higher retirement tax bracket assumption.
Key Factors Influencing Your IRA Choice
1. Current vs. Future Tax Rates
The single most important factor is comparing your current marginal tax rate with your expected tax rate in retirement. If you expect to be in a lower tax bracket during retirement, Traditional IRA typically makes more sense. If you expect to be in a higher tax bracket or want to lock in today’s relatively low rates, Roth IRA often becomes more attractive.
2. Time Until Retirement
Younger investors with decades until retirement often benefit more from Roth IRAs because:
- More time for tax-free compounding
- Likely lower current income (and tax bracket)
- Greater uncertainty about future tax rates
3. Income Level and Eligibility
Roth IRAs have income limits for direct contributions (2024: $161,000-$176,000 for singles, $240,000-$254,000 for married filing jointly). Traditional IRAs have no income limits for contributions, but deductibility may phase out based on income and workplace retirement plan participation.
4. Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)
Traditional IRAs require you to start taking minimum distributions at age 73 (75 if born in 1960 or later), potentially pushing you into higher tax brackets. Roth IRAs have no RMDs during your lifetime, allowing for continued tax-free growth and more flexible estate planning.
5. Withdrawal Flexibility
Roth IRAs offer unique flexibility: you can withdraw your contributions (but not earnings) at any time without taxes or penalties. Traditional IRA withdrawals before age 59½ generally incur a 10% penalty plus ordinary income tax, with few exceptions.
Advanced Considerations Beyond Basic Calculations
Tax Diversification Strategy
Many financial experts recommend maintaining both Roth and Traditional retirement accounts to create tax diversification. This strategy provides flexibility to manage taxable income in retirement, potentially allowing you to:
- Withdraw from Traditional accounts up to certain tax bracket limits
- Use Roth withdrawals for additional income without increasing tax liability
- Manage Medicare premium surcharges (IRMAA) by controlling taxable income
- Optimize Social Security taxation through strategic withdrawal sequencing
Roth Conversion Opportunities
During low-income years (career transitions, early retirement, etc.), you may have opportunities to convert Traditional IRA funds to Roth IRAs at lower tax rates than would apply during your peak earning years or required distribution periods.
Estate Planning Implications
Roth IRAs offer superior estate planning benefits:
- Heirs inherit tax-free distributions
- No RMDs during your lifetime means more assets can pass to beneficiaries
- Beneficiaries have 10 years to withdraw but distributions remain tax-free
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Avoid These IRA Planning Errors:
- Overestimating retirement tax rates: Most retirees actually fall into lower brackets
- Ignoring state taxes: Some states tax retirement income differently
- Forgetting about Social Security: Traditional IRA withdrawals can increase Social Security taxation
- Missing contribution deadlines: IRA contributions for a tax year can be made until April 15 of the following year
- Overlooking income limits: Verify eligibility before making contributions
Strategic Recommendations Based on Life Stages
For Young Professionals (20s-30s)
Priority: Roth IRA
Lower current tax brackets, decades for tax-free growth, and greater uncertainty about future rates make Roth particularly attractive for younger investors.
For Mid-Career Professionals (40s-50s)
Consider: Tax Diversification
Blend Roth and Traditional contributions based on current vs. expected retirement tax rates. Maximize catch-up contributions at age 50+.
For Pre-Retirees (60s)
Focus: Roth Conversions
Consider converting Traditional IRA funds to Roth during lower-income years before Social Security and RMDs begin.
For Retirees
Strategy: Withdrawal Sequencing
Use Traditional IRA withdrawals to fill lower tax brackets, then supplement with tax-free Roth withdrawals as needed.
Professional Guidance Recommendation
While our calculator provides valuable projections, important financial decisions should consider your complete financial picture. We recommend consulting with a qualified financial advisor or tax professional before making final decisions about IRA contributions, conversions, or withdrawals. They can help you navigate complex factors including estate planning, healthcare costs in retirement, and coordination with other retirement accounts.
Conclusion: Making an Informed Decision
Choosing between Roth and Traditional IRA involves analyzing multiple variables including your current financial situation, future expectations, tax considerations, and retirement goals. Our comprehensive calculator provides the analytical foundation for this important decision, but remember that the “best” choice depends on your individual circumstances.
The most successful retirement savers often employ a balanced approach, maintaining both Roth and Traditional accounts to create tax diversification and flexibility. Regular reviews of your strategy—especially when experiencing major life changes, income shifts, or tax law modifications—ensure your retirement savings remain optimally positioned for long-term success.
Key Takeaway
Whether you choose Roth, Traditional, or a combination of both, the most critical action is consistent, maximum-allowable contributions over time. Starting early, contributing regularly, and investing appropriately for your time horizon will have far greater impact on your retirement security than optimizing between Roth and Traditional accounts.
Thank you for using our Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA Calculator. We hope this tool and the accompanying information empower you to make confident, informed decisions about your retirement savings strategy.